Life in Group 5 – A Resto Shaman Blog
A resto shaman perspective on raiding


Uncategorized

July 7, 2010

Hello, my name is …

Hello My Name is Inigo Montoya

Believe you me, I tried to abstain from the discussion on this one. As bloggers everywhere took sides about the introduction of the Battle.net RealID system, I stayed silent. As guildies and former guildies sent me random emails saying “Let’s be RealID friends!” (including one from a former guildmaster with whom I didn’t have the best relationship, a wtf moment if I’ve ever had one), I stayed silent. As the forums erupted in discussions of invasion of privacy or use-at-your-own-risk, I stayed silent. Until today.

Yesterday will go down in internet gaming history as the day that Blizzard launched a major salvo against forum trolls and internet asshats and dared to suggest the establishment of a new precedent. In one swoop (although not yet implemented) Blizzard will attempt to pull back the veil of anonymity from the WoW forums and scare/embarrass the ill-mannered and ill-tempered into posting no more. From Battle.net’s forums:

The first and most significant change is that in the near future, anyone posting or replying to a post on official Blizzard forums will be doing so using their Real ID — that is, their real-life first and last name — with the option to also display the name of their primary in-game character alongside it.

The official forums have always been a great place to discuss the latest info on our games, offer ideas and suggestions, and share experiences with other players — however, the forums have also earned a reputation as a place where flame wars, trolling, and other unpleasantness run wild. Removing the veil of anonymity typical to online dialogue will contribute to a more positive forum environment, promote constructive conversations, and connect the Blizzard community in ways they haven’t been connected before. (Source)

Needless to say, I don’t think Blizzard anticipated the response they received. Bluetracker has been absolutely inundated with new threads, all subsequently closed by mods, condemning the change and calling for Blizzard to recant. And as much as I abhor making a scene, drawing lines in the sand, and delivering ultimatums, on this topic I’m willing to stick my neck out a bit and contribute to the fuss regarding the “RealName” (as I’m going to call it) forum launch, because this issue hits so very close to home.

 

The Problem Set

Although Blizzard didn’t divulge very much of their reasoning behind the RealName forum decision, I think it’s fairly safe to say that the problem they’re attempting to address is one suffered by forum boards near and far—heavy trolling and the disengagement from community participation that it encourages. For Blizzard, community participation is something that keeps interest in their product alive, and public perception is a key factor in maintaining, and growing, their market share. (In fact, I’ll bet that at some point, someone probably talked about the cost/benefit of blue forum posts. I know I would have!) So, it’s in their best interest, as a publically traded for-profit company, to give as many customers as possible a warm and fuzzy feeling. But in an internet environment, where people like you and I can demonstrate some of the worst malicious and antagonistic behaviors without fear of repercussion or punishment, Blizzard effectively has had very little leverage in the moderation of their own community.

 

Detractors from the RealName Argument

While I appreciate Blizzard’s attempts to make their forum community a more hospitable place, where good nature and helpfulness are commonplace, I cannot help but harbor a small amount of resentment for being placed in a position where I’m forced to choose between participating in a community that I take pride in being a part of and relinquishing my personal privacy. But, beyond that, through all of the discussions, rants, and commentaries that have been waged over the past 24 hours, a few key themes have emerged which I see as real counter-points for Blizzard’s proposed implementation:

 

1. Shame as a motivator

Interestingly enough, the change from forum names to RealName isn’t a substantial one at all for most people. It will likely have no affect on the actual content presented (although it potentially stands to remove some of the garbage) and will likely have no effect on the opinions players hold. Instead, what RealName seeks to do is inspire people through threat of public shame or ostracization, to treat others in a more socially acceptable manner. What this premise fails to address, as Greylo wonderfully put it, is that shame might still not be enough of a motivator to prevent the behavior that Blizzard is trying to avoid. In fact, with some it may likely have no weight at all. What strikes me about this approach is that it employs exactly the same tactics as peer pressure or mob mentality to effect the same result—that the target is isolated from the “mass”. Amazingly, this is contrary to one of things that I enjoy most about WoW—that players can unite in common interest without fear of being ostracized for being something other than “normal”.

 

2. Professional Impacts & the Gaming Stigma

As Miss Medicina so articulately stated, for many of us players and forums participants, the use of our real names has very serious professional implications. As I’ve mentioned before, I work in a professional industry as a consultant, where it is not uncommon to have potential clients type my name into a search field, to get more information about my experience and publications. These are clients who call me at 6pm on a Friday and ask if I can have a report ready by 9am on Monday; a not unreasonable request, because they pay for my time and pay for it well. But they are also paying for the professionalism that I demonstrate. And although I wish it were otherwise, the fact remains that I will be looked down upon were I to be found to be deeply involved in something as “trivial” as an online game. (And yes, my work oftentimes struggles to understand my “evening commitments” which predicate me from working 16-hour days.) For people like me, posting on Blizzard’s site (the only sure-fire way to provide them direct feedback about the game) will be an impossibility. Although it may frustrate me that my profession isn’t as hip as the gaming industry and as accepting of my extra-curricular activities, I would never dream of putting my job on the line to contribute my thoughts on the latest shaman changes.

 

3. Public Exposure & Accessibility

I had a system admin friend who once advised me, quite sagely: “Complete network security is an illusion. Anything can be hacked given someone with enough time, resources, and dedication. Your ‘security’ is just there to try to get in their way.” And since reaching the age where Point 2 (above) has started to matter more to me, I’ve taken this advice to heart. I don’t Facebook, I don’t MySpace, and I’m very careful what information about me I make public. But given enough time and Google dedication, I’m quite sure a determined reader would find out everything there is to know about the real me. Just like I’m sure that if someone wanted into my home, they could find a way. The point, as Bashiok so discovered, is to not make it easy. Blizzard’s forums, like most other forums and comment boards, are in the predicament of being privately managed space open to the public, which means they are just about as accessible as anything else you might put out there. But, in an online community where temperatures run high over things as simple as a change to Pennace or nerf to Rage generation, this potential exposure borders on dangerous.

 

4. MMO*RP*G

In all of the discussion, I honestly see the most compelling argument against RealName as being the very genre that WoW is credited as having made available to people worldwide. Massive Multi-player Online Role Playing Games can range from pseudo-reality to intensely fantastical, but the one characteristic of them all is that I, the player, am *pretending* to be something else. I am not a virtual me; I am a commando, jedi, fleet commander, or giant blue troll. I am male, female, machine, or beast, and I am not necessarily human. As much as I may groan and whine over the extensive RP incorporated into WoW (how many times do I have to listen to your speech, Tirion?!) the fact remains that WoW is built around my involvement in a fantastical environment. When I play WoW, I am Vixsyn, Vix, Tartlet, Psyrin, and a host of other characters. I write from their perspective, I argue on their behalf, because that is a part of the nature of the game. Without the RP elements, WoW becomes an odd mix of Facebook and Second Life instead of the genre-defining force it truly is.

 

One player’s decision

In the end, like so many other players and bloggers have said, the road to hell is paved in good intentions. I wholeheartedly applaud Blizzard’s attempt to make the forums a valuable resource for the community, just as I applaud their efforts to engage their customers through Blue poster’s constant presence on those forums. But as much of a cheerleader as I am for Blizzard’s past decisions, I simply do not see RealName as a way to reach the end goal that they’re striving for. Utilizing community disdain and public exposure as consequences for bad behavior strikes me as an incredibly inappropriate solution when the potential for increased moderation (a la EJ) and a unified account identifier, could be implemented without such extreme adverse consequences or the loss of community participation.

Ultimately, the result is that players like me, those who see the potential risks inherent in participation, will turn away from the forums for good. As much as it is my driving desire to help the community, to participate in the discussion, to improve the game as much as I can, it will come at too great a price. I’ll turn to other outlets which let me guard my privacy as an author and as a person, and I doubt it will be a minor inconvenience to anyone other than me.

I think the Supreme Court justices put it best, when addressing the issue of the right of anonymity of an author (albeit a political one, in this case):

“Despite readers’ curiosity and the public’s interest … an author generally is free to decide whether or not to disclose her true identity. The decision in favor of anonymity may be motivated by fear of economic or official retaliation, by concern about social ostracism, or merely by a desire to preserve as much of one’s privacy as possible. Whatever the motivation may be, at least in the field of literary endeavor, the interest in having anonymous works enter the marketplace of ideas unquestionably outweighs any public interest in requiring disclosure as a condition of entry. [n.5] Accordingly, an author’s decision to remain anonymous, like other decisions concerning omissions or additions to the content of a publication, is an aspect of the freedom of speech protected by the First Amendment.

The right to remain anonymous may be abused when it shields fraudulent conduct. But … in general, our society accords greater weight to the value of free speech than to the dangers of its misuse.” (As referenced in: McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Comm’n (93-986), 514 U.S. 334 (1995) )






18 Comments


  1. But given enough time and Google dedication, I’m quite sure a determined reader would find out everything there is to know about the real me.

    This is especially bad for people like myself – I have a unique enough name that the first page and a half of Google results are my blog, my “professional” website, various creative efforts I’ve attached my name to. I’m not really shy of attaching my name to these things because really, outside of my group of personal friends, there’s very little to draw random strangers to me. Sure, i’m trying to create a professional website, but it’s just one of those “I have it on standby in case I actually start WRITING” things. Everything else is… utterly uninteresting, if you don’t know me, so the people who I attract to these sites generally KNOW me already.

    My WoW blog and associated persona, on the other hand, are completely separate. I admit, a good portion of that has been because I’m a bit embarrassed (irrationally so) to admit to most of my friends that I write a WoW blog. But I don’t link the two – Apple doesn’t link to anything my “real” persona does, and my “real” persona doesn’t link to anything Apple does. I have an entirely unrelated email address associated with Apple (though I’m sure I’ve slipped up a couple places commenting and used my personal email, I trust that those bloggers don’t give a crap and won’t sell that information XD).

    If my name were to suddenly be associated with my characters, my presence in the WoW community, a quick Google search could lead any would-be stalkers directly and immediately, with very little effort, to my personal site, wherein they could find enough information to likely track me down IN PERSON if they wished.

    I would not put it past some people. Not many, but some.
    .-= Apple´s last blog ..Brief Update =-.


  2. Augh, I totally don’t fail at finishing my points. Part of what I was going to say is that while part of the reason I have, in past, kept my personas separate is because I’m a little shy of letting my RL friends see my blog, I also was running a blog that generally got 12-17 views when a new post would go up. Then I started commenting more, and my average popped up to about 25 views when there was a new post.

    After posting about the RealName forum issue just before midnight last night, I’ve gotten just shy of 200 views today alone.

    Small beans compared to the readership of most blogs I follow? Yes. Will I get that many views the next time I post? Probably not. But it is proving that my reader base is growing, and in light of RealName I go from being “some random chick named X posting on the forums” to, for some people, “that chick who writes the Azeroth Apple blog”. People can get scarily worked up over a game. People can get scarily worked up over something a blogger says about something.

    I love having readers, but in some ways, more readers mean more reasons to keep Apple and my personal life separate.
    .-= Apple´s last blog ..Brief Update =-.


  3. Zulrea

    I agree with you wholeheartedly. I think this is one of the biggest mistakes Blizzard has made in a very long time. You would think that the stock dropping, and all these people complaining would make them second guess what they are doing. /sigh GG Blizzard GG.


  4. Very, very well said.
    .-= Kaethir´s last blog ..A Primer on Kitty DPS- Part 2 The Spec and Glyphs =-.


  5. InfiniteIce

    This is absolutely AMAZING.

    I have linked your article in the TeamLiquid forums, here: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=134327&currentpage=139#2763

    PROPS. Seriously. I <3 you.


  6. InfiniteIce

    Also, feel free to merge this into the above post, or just take it yourself privately, I don’t have any preference.

    But I feel you may be getting another hit of viewers soon.

    You’ve been linked to on the WoW forums by others, and on the TeamLiquid forums by myself.

    (TL is the single largest StarCraft: Brood War and StarCraft II community in existence. I frequent there daily.)

    I linked to you because you seriously need more viewers if this has only gotten 200 views.

    To put it in a (less-than?) eloquent fashion, this is win.


  7. Thanks for the positive feedback on this, everyone. I sincerely hope that Blizzard is listening to the feedback from the community and the suggestions that are being put forth because there are a number of brilliant minds out there who have thrown in their 2 cents (far beyond the couple I linked to in this piece. (In fact, I find the overwhelming community response slightly ironic because it likely wouldn’t be the case if the RealName announcement preceded immediate implementation on the forums!)


  8. An excellent synopsis of what is driving the community as a whole bananas at the moment. However, a fellow guildie linked me this: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/zeroday/2010/07/07/is-korean-law-driving-policy-at-blizzard/

    It might not have anything to do with this, but if it has, it might explain the reasoning behind the change.

    cheers,

    Zorkolak


  9. theq

    I despise the RealID concept and the more I read about it, the more my stomach turns. The post on the official forums is now 2400+ pages and many people are hoping that Blizzard will respond favourably to our concerns and reasonably alter or kill RealID. Unfortunately, there is very little chance of that happening. Seeing as Blizzard is owned by Activision, Mike Morheim reports directly to Tom Tuppl, who reports directly to Bobby Kotick who doesn’t give a rats ass what you or I want. He has made a deal with Facebook and he is going to leverage that deal to make as much money as humanly possible no matter what and count on the fact that the majority of the WoW community does not have the fortitude to resist this effort with their wallets. It pains me greatly to see Blizzard, a once respected developer of amazing IPs to be subject to the machinations of a slimy, greedy scumbag like Kotick but that is the world we live in.

    Otherwise, I really enjoy your blog. It is considerate and well written, keep up the good work, hopefully in SWTOR.


  10. Jen

    The main issue for me is the fact that I am female….dangerous.


  11. Excellent find, Zork! I had no idea that this type of battle had been waged before (albeit with Google’s considerable weight behind it). Still, it seems like something like South Korean policy would be better handled on the local level than worldwide (similar to the reskinning applied to undead character in Chinese markets).

    As for the giant conspiracy theory, Activision is a for-profit company; they’re entrepreneurs, not philanthropists. So their goal is to ensure demand for a product, so that they can all remain employed. But it’s an incredibly fine line to walk when you have a consumer base as diverse and as invested as WoW’s is, and while I may scoff at plushie sales, sparkly mounts, and auction house apps, I appreciate that the cash flow they provide enables Blizzard to produce a product that I value and provide consistent service and upgrades to it.

    Like I said, the data that they’re proposing to share is available in spades all across the internet, and is likely something you freely reveal when you join up with a guild or with players that you get to know. The difference here isn’t that this information will now be available online, it’s that you personally didn’t choose to put it out there.


  12. Theq

    In a shocking reversal, Mike Morhaime posts a retraction of the RealID forum changes, for now. I must say, I am truly shocked. Still, Activision has perpetrated a disastrous breech of trust on this one. It is conceivable that as Facebook is integrated further into World of Warcraft the Real Name forum changes will be re-instituted. We will have to wait and see, with fingers hovering over the ‘cancel account’ button.


  13. [...] of Grey OutDPS Kurn’s Corner Life in Group 5 Mental Shaman Preposterous Pretentious Prattle Binds to Account Gnomeaggedon TankSpot World of [...]


  14. I feel that the best solution would be to have the Blizzard community police itself. It would reduce the amount of manpower needed to moderate the forums, which I dread to think of. But sites like Epic Advice have shown that focused, self-imposed policing is possible.

    In all honesty, I have no idea how to implement such a scheme on the scale of the Blizzard forums but then again there has to be a better way then to violate everyone’s privacy.


  15. Cortizo

    Gotta love the Princess Bride reference. =D


  16. [...] up the opportunity to blog about RealID (on forums anyways) when it came out. First because I knew the blogosphere would explode over that and second because I was rather sure the thing won’t ever go live [...]


  17. AForgottenComment

    While I am glad they seemed to listen…….why is everyone, including the posting love going on on their forums, overlooking this:

    “Over time, we will continue to evolve Real ID on Battle.net to add new and exciting functionality within our games for players who decide to use the feature. ”

    Absolutely everyone is professing their love again for blizzard…..woah wait….back that horse up…..They just got done double talking everyone….the means it’s GOING to be done, just not now.

    Else……why be so middle of the road with comments like that instead of giving an outright “not going to happen not ever” instead of the “for now” statement….

    Is it me, or are people just not reading the thing in it’s entirety? Sure seems the masses skipped this line or didn’t care.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge